Catalog :




Detail Article

Masyarakat, Kebudayaan dan Politik

ISSN Lama 0216-2407, Baru 2086-7050

Vol. 13 / No. 1 / Published : 2000-01

Related with : Scholar   Yahoo!   Bing

Original Article :

A critique of democratic peace theory

Author :

  1. Sartika Soesilowati*1
  1. FISIP Universitas Airlangga, Jl. Airlangga 4-6 Surabaya, 60286, Indonesia.

Abstract :

Tulisan ini mengkritisi teori normatif yang menyatakan (1) bahwa negara-negara demokrasi yang meyakini dan menjalankan lembaga-lembaga dan nilai-nilai demokrasi cenderung mengurangi motivasi untuk berperang, (2) bahwa perang tidak pernah atau jarang terjadi antarnegara demokratis, dan (3) bahwa perang banyak terjadi antarnegara bukan demokratis, atau antara negara demokratis dengan negara tidak demokratis. Pendapat normatif itu tidak mampu meyakinkan penstudi hubungan internasional, karena teori itu dibangun atas dasar (1) definisi demokrasi yang masih kontroversial dan tidak cukup jelas, (2) data empirik yang terbatas dan tidak akurat, dan (3) ketidaktegasan hubungan sebab-akibat antara demokrasi dan perang.

Keyword :

demokrasi / democracy, damai / peace, perang / war, teori perdamaian demokratik / democratic peace theory,


References :

  1. Steve Chan, (1997). In Search of Democratic Peace: Problem and Promise. :
  2. Michael Doyle, (1996). Kant, Liberal Legacies, and Foreign Affairs. London : MIT Press
  3. Miriam Fendius Elman, (1997). Paths to Peace: Is Democracy the Answer? . London : MIT Press
  4. Henry S Farber, (0000). Polities and Peace. :
  5. Joanne Gowa, (0000). Polities and Peace. :
  6. N. Gleditsch, (1992). Democracy and Peace. :
  7. Joanne Gowa, (1995). Democratic Peace and International Disputes. :
  8. Stanley Hoffman, (1995). The Crisis of Liberal Internationalism. :
  9. Wade L. Huntley, (1996). Kant's Third Image Systemic Sources of the Liberal Peace. :
  10. Arie M. Kacowitz, (1995). Explaining Zones of Peace: Democracies as Satisfied Powers?. :
  11. Christopher Layne, (1994). Kant or Cant: the Myth of the Democratic Peace. :
  12. Charles William Maynes, (1993). Workable Clinton Doctrine. :
  13. John J. Mearsheimer, (1990). Back to the Future: Instability in Europe After the Cold War. :
  14. Ido Oren, (1995). Subjectivity of the Democratic Peace: Changing US Perception of Imperial Germany. :
  15. Harries-Clichy, Jr. Peterson, (1997). Democracy and Security in the Post Cold War Era. Canberra : Allen and Unwin
  16. James Lee Ray, (1995). Democracy and Inter-national Conflict: an Evaluation of the Democratic Peace Proposition. Columbia : University of South Carolina Press
  17. David E Spiro, (1994). The Insignificance of the Liberal Peace. :
  18. Waltz Waltz, (1999). Never Say Never: Wishful Thinking on Democracy and War. :
  19. Fareed Zakaria, (1997). The Rise of Illiberal Democracy. :


   


Archive Article

Cover Media Content

Volume : 13 / No. : 1 / Pub. : 2000-01
  1. Revitalization of folk culture to develop the quality of human resources
  2. The roles of ethnicity, class, and race in american political behavior: the case of african americans
  3. The role of interest groups and campaign contributions to the american political system: a critical view
  4. The role of ilo in the empowerment of indonesian labors
  5. The transformation of organization management
  6. Rethinking of the sustainable development in surabaya
  7. A critique of democratic peace theory
  8. Organisasi partai politik dan demokrasi
  9. Ekonomi politik pangan dan problema petani